Skip to Content

How to Fix Jello Shots That Didn’t Set

A Jell-O shot is a mixture of gelatin and alcohol, mostly popular with grown-ups. It is made by mixing alcohol in the already-made gelatin mixture, replacing some amount of water added to the gelatin.

You can fix Jell-O shots by dissolving them and adding more bloomed gelatin. Place them in the fridge for a couple of hours to set properly. If Jell-O shots won’t set, it also means that they haven’t been chilled in the fridge for long enough. 

The amount of water is an important part of mixing Jell-O and letting the gelatin bloom. If the gelatin didn’t bloom correctly, you wouldn’t be able to make fine Jell-O shots. Many factors will influence how the Jell-O sets, and we bring you all the details you need to know to make them properly.

Colorful jello shots

How to fix Jell-O shots that didn’t set?

Jell-O preparation requires combining the gelatin with hot boiling water, adding the required quantity of cold water, and setting the final product for a few hours in the refrigerator. While it seems straight-forward enough, there are several ways to screw up Jell-O, especially when adding additional ingredients, such as fruit, to the recipe.

If your Jell-O shots didn’t set, you could try to save them. However, if Jell-O shots can’t be salvaged, you’ll need to start the process anew. But you should be able to make a final product that sets properly by following some simple tips at the beginning.

Jell-O Shots are a blend of alcohol, flavored gelatin and water. They are semi-solid and are mostly served in paper or plastic cups that are disposable. The most common alcohol associated with Jell-O Shots is vodka, but you can use any alcohol you choose. Some people use rum and tequila, as well.

When preparing it from scratch, dissolve the gelatin in hot water until the cold water is applied to the mix. If, when applying cold water, the gelatin is not fully dissolved, it will not set properly.

Put the Jell-O in the fridge and let it sit for at least six hours. If you leave it to sit overnight, cover the Jell-O pan with plastic wrap. This will avoid the hardening of the Jell-O and allow it to be set correctly.

The normal time to chill the Jell-O in the refrigerator is six hours, but it’ll also depend upon what proportion or what quite a gelatin you’ve got, whether you have a large quantity or your Jell-O poured into thick molds or Jell-O containing fruits. It would help if you cooled it overnight, as it can keep Jell-O from hardening and set properly by wrapping the mixture with plastic wrap.

The Jell-O that is not set may also be repaired by heating it or mixing in more bloomed gelatin. In fact, lukewarm water is preferred rather than boiling water, but ensure the gelatin is fully dissolved before cold water is applied, or it won’t set properly.

If you’re using fruit, remove all the bits and pieces, as those will make it harder for your Jell-O to sit. Breaking down the gelatin is an enzyme that stops it from settling properly and is found in fruits such as guava, figs, ginger, papaya, pineapple, and kiwi.

When cooking double the amount of Jell-O, add just 1.5 times the amount of salt, vinegar, and other wet ingredients the recipe calls for. Add double the amount of gelatin, liquid, and fruit as you double the formula, but do not ration other ingredients the same way, such as lemon juice or salt.

You shouldn’t, under any circumstance, add pineapple juice to the Jell-O shots. Due to the chemistry of the pineapple, it prevents the Jell-O from setting. Pineapple contains bromelain, a chemical that contains two protein-digesting enzymes called proteases.

Other fruits contain proteases that can also ruin the gelatin. The figs, fresh ginger root, papaya, guava, mango, and kiwi fruit are examples. Using some of these fresh fruits with gelatin will prevent forming the collagen fibers, so the gelatin does not firm up. Luckily, deactivating the enzymes is simple so that they won’t pose a problem.

You can use fresh fruit with gelatin, but first adding heat to denature the protein molecules. If they have been heated to about 158 ° F, the enzymes in bromelain are inactivated. Although fresh pineapple prevents Jell-O from the setting, using canned pineapple won’t be a problem.

Pile of Jello Cubes

Why does my Jell-O not set?

If you put too much alcohol in a Jell-O shot, it will not set. In general, one cup of juice or water, one packet of gelatin, half a half a cup of alcohol and half a cup of water make up a simple batch of Jell-O Shots. You’ll end up with a Jell-O Shot with these proportions, which is about 10 percent ABV.

Any fruits will prevent the proper setting of Jell-O, not only because of the quality of water but due to chemical reactions. Essentially, gelatin is a protein. Typically extracted from collagen, usually animal protein, the enzyme may break down this substance.

When the Jell-O does not set, the only thing you can do is add more gelatin to the mixture. If you are working with animal gelatin, you need to dissolve the granules in cold water, and then you should carefully melt it in steam and add it to the mixture.

Jell-O must be prepared and cooled according to the box instructions for it to set. If the Jell-O has not been set, you have either added too much sugar, added too much fruit with too much water, or are trying to get it set in a spot other than the refrigerator.

Mix a 3 oz box of Jell-O with one cup of boiling water. Mix until the Jell-O is dissolved, then add to the not-set formula. Keep it in the fridge until it sets. The box offers fruit addition tips on the side of it.

If the Jell-O didn’t set, you have probably mixed it with the wrong amount of water or heat. Until heat supports the gelatin particles to hydrate and thoroughly absorb moisture, the gelatin will not grow. Many people wouldn’t want to boil the alcohol, but there won’t be a set with just warm water. Use a water-to-alcohol proportion of 1:2 or 1:3.

Many problems can occur when you’re preparing the Jell-O that won’t allow it to set. Most of these problems occur while you’re preparing it and not paying attention to the box itself.

The first problem is the bloom of Jell-O. The strength of Jell-O is measured on a scale from 0 up to 325. If the number on the box is higher, it means that the gelatin is stronger. For example, America’s standard strength of gelatin is 230, while in Europe the standard is 250. If you’re following an online recipe, check to see what kind of Jell-O they’re using and follow the exact instructions.

The box also gives instructions on how much heat to use. Gelatin’s intensity reduces quickly above 212°F or is kept for an extended period of time at that temperature. Curiously, heat-induced disruption influences rigidity, not viscosity. It is best if you make sure that when you’re adding Jell-O to something, it does not exceed the temperature of 212°F. Also, try not to put a Jell-O mix in a complete boil, or you will risk losing their thickening properties.

Sugar is also an ingredient that you have to keep an eye on. If you put a small amount of sugar in a recipe, it will speed up the formation of Jell-O, but it can also create a weaker set because sugar can increase the rigidity of gelatin in the correct amount. If you feel that the recipe for Jell-O calls for too much sugar, you balance that sugar by adding some salt.

Acid and pH levels also affect how the Jell-O forms. As we mentioned before, certain fruits, such as lemon and lime, can affect the gelatin. Acid shits the gelatin from one point to another and sometimes causes it not to set correctly. Always read the recipe thoroughly and watch how you should prepare the Jell-O.

Why is my Jell-O watery?

Give 1 to 2 2 cups of solids, either minced, cubed, or broken into small parts, for every 2 cups of mixture. To stop watering down the gelatin, make sure to remove all the liquid of solid pieces before applying them to the gelatin.

Several recipes require 2-cups of liquid per 1-pack of Jell-O. But many individuals choose 1 3⁄4 cups of liquid per 1-packet. This makes a stiffer mixture that keeps the gelatin mold’s shape nicely.

Instead of a smooth texture you might end up with clumps if you only pour gelatin powder onto a base. You should “bloom” the gelatin first to eliminate this. To correctly bloom the gelatin in Jell-O, sprinkle the Jell-O in cold water first and mix it. Let it sit in cold water for up to 5 minutes, and you can put it in warm water.

Some liquids, including fruit juices, clarified vegetable or meat stocks, vegetable juices, and broths, can be used in place of water to prepare the gelatin. As the veal contains more collagen that gels the stock, the thicker stock, and a more delicate taste comes from using veal bones rather than other meat bones.

To make sure that your Jell-O sets correctly, you have to prepare it according to the box’s instructions. As long as it is packed airtight and kept in a cold, dry spot, unprepared gelatin has an infinite shelf life, but it can clump.

If the Jell-O is too watery, it means that it is not setting correctly. The problem can also be if you’re trying to bloom and mix the Jell-O with lukewarm water. The gelatin can be bloomed with cold water and then added into warm water. The alternative is to add hot water first, then the Jell-O, and then the cold water.

The protein bonds in Jell-O are not set in the mixture itself. Hot water unravels and expands the bonds so the Jell-O can set properly. The temperature of the water will affect how the Jell-O will react.

If you added too much water, the only solution is to add more of the Jell-O mixture. Keep adding the mixture until you get the right consistency. Just remember that the excess liquid needs to be substituted with solids.

You should also add a splash of flavoring to accompany your blend, based on how many extra wet ingredients you have added, maybe 3x as much as required or more. The other tip is to cook a little longer. If you are keeping the Jell-O on the heat and not getting the right consistency, keep it on the fire and mix.

The more your completed recipe sits, the more it becomes solidified. This is why, on the first day, Jell-O will taste better than on the fifth day. Cold temperatures make the gelatin stronger as well. Put It in the freezer for a couple of minutes if you’re running late and you don’t have time to let the Jell-O settle down.

For more, don’t miss Can You Put Jello In The Freezer? (To Make It Set Faster).