Sam’s Club vs. Costco: Which Is Better for Emergency Food Prepping?

Both warehouse giants offer bulk deals and prepping staples, but when it comes to taste, value, and packaging, there are a few key differences worth knowing.

Let’s break it down.

---

🍲 Taste and Texture: Which Feels More Like Real Food?

If you’re aiming for food your family will actually eat during a crisis, taste matters. Based on reviews and firsthand experience:

• Costco offers ReadyWise and Mountain House brands more consistently, both known for decent texture and flavor. Mountain House especially scores high in taste tests (see: Best Freeze-Dried Meals for Preppers).
• Sam’s Club typically stocks Augason Farms and some store-branded mixes. Augason is hit-or-miss—their fruit and powdered eggs are solid, but some entrees have been reported to be bland or overly salty.

Winner: Costco (especially if Mountain House is in stock)

---

💸 Price Per Serving: Bulk Value Breakdown

Here’s a quick glance at pricing for comparable items:

Item	Sam’s Club	Costco
Augason Farms Breakfast Kit	$59.98 (162 servings)	N/A
ReadyWise 124-Serving Bucket	N/A	$74.99
#10 Can Powdered Eggs	$28.98 (Sam’s)	$34.99 (Costco)

• Sam’s Club tends to win on price-per-serving, especially when buying Augason Farms in bulk.
• Costco shines when they run deals on bundles or have Mountain House multipacks.

Winner: Sam’s Club for price; Costco for quality bundles

---

🏦 Packaging and Storage Options

• Sam’s Club: Offers a lot of items in stackable food storage pails. Great for long-term stacking and rotation.
• Costco: Sells buckets, #10 cans, and multipacks. Variety is better, especially if you’re mixing and matching for nutritional diversity.

Winner: Tie – Costco gives more flexibility, Sam’s gives more uniformity.

---

📊 Pro Tip: Combine Strategies

If you’re serious about prepping, you don’t have to choose one or the other. Many preppers buy their staples (like powdered eggs, milk, fruit) from Sam’s Club for price, and grab higher-quality meals or protein-focused foods (like chili mac or breakfast skillet) from Costco.

See How to Buy Freeze-Dried Food on a Budget for more ways to mix and match sources.

---

🛒 Step-by-Step: How to Get the Most Value

1. Compare Price Per Serving (Not Just Per Pound)
That 30-pound bucket may look like a steal, but always check how many actual meals it provides—and whether those meals are complete. Some brands bulk with rice or pasta and skimp on protein. Use the cost-per-serving rule of thumb, especially when comparing options at Sam’s vs. Costco.

2. Look for Mylar + Oxygen Absorber Packaging
Skip anything in just a plastic bucket without sealed liners. Proper storage = longer shelf life. This ties directly into our full guide: How to Store Freeze-Dried Food for Maximum Shelf Life.

3. Stack Sales with Instant Rebates and Store Promos
Both clubs run rolling discounts. Use their apps or websites to catch markdowns on emergency food kits, powdered eggs, and even fuel or water storage.

4. Test Taste Before You Buy Big
If you’re new to a brand, grab a sampler box or smaller pouch set before committing to a 72-hour bucket.

5. Don’t Ignore Add-Ons
Look for deals on powdered butter, peanut butter powder, and fruit. These “extras” are often skipped but add flavor and calories that boost morale.

Final Verdict:

• Best for budget staples: Sam’s Club
• Best for taste, texture & variety: Costco
• Best overall? Depends on what you’re building. Use both if you can.

For more on storing what you buy, check out How to Store Freeze-Dried Food for Maximum Shelf Life.

---

Related Reads:

• 7 Cheapest Places to Buy Freeze-Dried Foods
• Can You Freeze-Dry Food at Home? (Pros, Costs, and What You Need)

Thanks for stoppin’ by!

Jelly Grandma