The 5 Most Durable Archery Targets

Archery takes a lot of time, patience, and practice to master. You’ll probably miss many shots before you start hitting the target. A top-quality target can be a big help in your messy path to victory on your newly found skill. In this post, we’ve prepared a brief list for you. 

We assessed several targets against a wide range of variables, including material type, weather resistance, ease of use, stopping power, expected life, and much more. As a bonus, they are all conveniently available on Amazon. Let’s dig in. 

1. Best Budget: Hurricane Bag Archery Target

Not long ago, straw targets were the norm. Straw was and is still good, although bag-form targets like the Hurricane Bag make for even better and more durable targets for your shooting practice. 

On the outside, the Hurricane Bag archery target features a printed black and neon green color pattern on a rigid nylon cover. A heavy-duty nylon handle protrudes from the top side so you can easily switch between practice sites.

On the inside, the Hurricane Bag contains a weatherproof fill designed to take on high-velocity arrows from powerful bows and crossbows without any of them really sticking out the back. 

Hurricane Bag Archery Target Features

• 2-sided target built with durable tri-core technology 
• Visible aiming dots that are easy to see against all kinds of backgrounds 
• Off-centered deer vitals 
• Stops high-performance, 400-600fps arrows 
• Available in 3 sizes (20, 25, and 28 inches or 50.8, 63.5, and 71 cm) 

How Durable Is the Hurricane Bag?

When we talk about durability, we’re mainly talking about the number of arrows it takes before it starts to look beat up. 

A hurricane bag can take hundreds of arrows and last anywhere between two to four months before it starts to wear out. After that, you can use it for a couple of years. The type of arrow fired, its power, and distance are all factors determining how long the bag lasts. 

Field Logic guarantees that the Hurricane Bag can survive whatever you throw at it–-from hundreds of arrows to forces of nature. The stuffing material is dense and impermeable to mold, mildew, rot, and severe weather. 

Additionally, Hurricane’s tri-core technology can take an impact of up to 1000 psi (6895 kPa) You can shoot as many arrows as you like on either side from 20, 50, or 70 yards out (18.3, 45.7, or 64 meters) and it will still hold on. The covers are easy to remove and replace. 

Pros

• Easily portable thanks to its heavy-duty handle 
• Suitable for long-range practice 
• Durable target with a long service life 
• Does not give way to arrows easily 
• Arrows are easy to remove 

Cons

• Sometimes, arrows get stuck. 
• Only suitable for field points 
• Doesn’t stand straight without back support. 
• Not good with low draws and high-power crossbows 
• Arrows may rip the surface on the way out. 

What we like the most about the Hurricane Bag is its durability. Thanks to its rigid construction, weight, fill, and cover, you can expect yours to comfortably take a beating for years to come. 

2. Best for Broadheads: Black Hole 61212 Crossbow Target

Black Hole’s 61212 target is yet another high-performance, heavy-duty target designed to take on powerful arrows and crossbow bolts moving at 400 fps.

At such power, not all targets can stop a projectile without taking a good hit. If that’s not bad enough, try using a broadhead on a lighter target and see what damage it can do. 

The Black Hole 61212 crossbow target is built for field points and broadheads. Whether you’re using a high-performance crossbow at a close range or just trying out archery from a few yards, here are some of the features you’ll work with: 

Black Hole 61212 Crossbow Target Features

• 4-sided (cube-shaped) with more targets to train with 
• Stops crossbows with speeds of up to 400fps 
• Lightweight and waterproof
• Wooden top
• Made of durable, weather-resistant polypropylene 

A crossbow hunter with a Black Hole 61212 crossbow target can shoot arrows from the front, back, and any of the two sides. The front and backsides can take field points and broadheads, while the side targets are wrapped in polypropylene for field points only. 

Pros

• Great for crossbows 
• Multi-purpose
• Easy arrow removal 
• Easy to carry 
• Portable
• Great value

Cons

• Could have a better design
• Has a wooden top that shouldn’t be shot at
• Arrows travel way too deep into the stuffing 
• Not suitable for crossbows at 20-30 yards out (18.3 – 27.4 meters) 

How Durable Is the Black Hole 61212 Crossbow Target?

The compact design of the Black Hole 61212 is a thing to look at. The target can stand on its own, stop arrows with ease, and do so much more. In terms of how long it can last, here’s what to expect: 

The Black Hole 61212 Crossbow Target can last from a couple of months to 2-3 years on normal use. With frequent use, the target only lasts between 5 months to a year and a couple of months before the cover or all of it needs replacement.

This is not to say that yours can’t serve for a long time. Black Hole targets are built to last for years, depending on how many arrows you shoot a day, the power behind each draw, and how well you take care of your target. Just don’t expect it to look new after 5 months.

Related How To Make a Homemade Crossbow Target | 2 Different Methods.

3. BIGSHOT Archery Titan 16

Ever placed a target on the ground and just wished that the target zone would be slightly tilted upwards? It’s frustrating for your target to be just close to the perfect angle for aiming your arrows. Well, worry no more. The BIGSHOT Archery Titan 16 has you covered. 

This target comes with five tapered shooting zones, each with a tilt that matches the angle you’re shooting at. When standing, the shooting zones will be perpendicular to your angle of sight.

Additionally, you get not two, but five tapered target zones to keep practicing on. And that’s not all. The tapered design also helps in saving space for traveling and storage. 

Here are other features: 

Features

• Five-sided broadhead target that prepares archers for different phases of target archery 
• Made of elasto-flex self-healing foam designed to stop broadheads and field points 
• Able to stop crossbows with speed ratings up to 500fps 
• A tape design that positions the target face perpendicular to the archer’s shooting plane 

The BIGSHOT Titan is lightweight and made with a handle at the top, making it convenient for the user to carry it to any location, wether it’s indoors or outdoors. 

Pros

• Stops arrows and bolts easily 
• Suitable for heavy-duty use 
• Easy arrow removal 
• Very portable 

Cons

• Tight grip on bolts
• A bit expensive

How Durable Is the BIGSHOT Titan?

The BIGSHOT Titan 16 is, without doubt, a worthy choice for your next target. Other than its very tight grip on high-velocity arrows and bolts, there aren’t many downsides to it. Sadly, the price runs on the higher side. However, this is a small sacrifice for a high-quality target that will last a long time. 

The BIGSHOT Titan can last a year before you have to replace it with a new one. The Elasto-Flex self-healing foam keeps the target together after thousands of shots. However, be very careful when pulling out an arrow. If necessary, use an arrow lube to avoid damaging the stuffing. 

For anyone looking for an archery target that will definitely improve their shooting game, the BIGshot Titan 16 should be on their list.

4. Morrell Double Duty 450FPS

Morrell is a family-owned business with a wide variety of archery bags in the market. Everything from the name to the design says that the Morrell Double Duty is a durable archery target that will last you for years to come. 

For starters, the target is designed for field points, which it can take comfortably from crossbows and compound bows. The four sides offer a varied selection of targets: deer vitals, nine balls, bullseye points, and a printed dartboard. 

Morrell Double Duty Features

Morrel double duty features that make it stand out include: 

• 4 different targets
• Stops 400fps arrows
• High-quality replaceable fabric 
• Made of weatherproof polypropylene 
• Easy arrow removal 

Morrell Double Duty is also made of a high-quality burlap body and super fill stuffing. This allows for easy arrow removal. Two handles come out at the top for easy transportation. 

But, just like any other product, the Morrell Double Duty has drawbacks as well as benefits: 

Pros

• Good value
• Easy to carry 
• Takes blows from compound bows and crossbows 
• Easy arrow removal
• Long-lasting
• Multiple target options
• Can take fast-moving arrows

Cons

• Has some visibility issues 
• Arrows can be somewhat difficult to remove if they go deep
• May damage fletching 
• Relatively heavy 

How Long Does Morrell Double Duty Last?

A high-end target like the Morrel Double Duty should withstand the harshest elements and live for generations. And that’s exactly what it does.  

Morrell Double Duty can last two years at the very least, as long as you stick to field points only. Broadheads can tear up the polypropylene stuffed inside and do even more damage to the external cover. The target comes with a 2-year warranty. 

If you read through the skeptical reviews online, you might be surprised by some dissenting opinions. But we believe that when it comes to durability, field point practice, weatherproofing, and arrow removal, nothing beats the Morrell Double Duty. 

Check out how to take good care of your Morrell Target for prolonged service life.

5. Rinehart® 18-1 Broadhead Target

Want a target that will help you take your shooting game to the next level? Check out the Rinehart 18-1 target: an octa-decagon-shaped target with 18 different target zones and over 40 shootable dots at different angles. 

Whichever side you’re on, you’ll have something to shoot at. And once you make your shot, all you have to do is turn the target to a new side and keep on shooting. You also have the advantage of being able to practice with targets tilted at different angles.

As easy as it is to put arrows into the target, it’s also easy to pull them out. You don’t have to yank it to the extent of almost pulling your arm off. Last but not least, the target has a perfect size and weight. You can carry it anywhere you want with its strong handle. 

Here are a few features to expect from your Rinehart archery target: 

Rinehart® 18-1 Broadhead Target Features

• 18 target zones 
• In-built handle for easy transportation 
• Lightweight and small in size compared to other targets 
• Can take crossbows with speed ratings of over 400fps. 
• Made of self-healing foam for extra durability 

You’ve seen self-healing foam a couple times before on this list. On your Rinehart target, you’re guaranteed that it will remain intact for a long time. The self-healing foam is also weatherproof and can take a beating from extreme temperatures and moisture. 

Pros

• Quiet and apt for using indoors
• Its small size makes it ideal for travelers. 
• Top-of-the-line performance

Cons

• High price
• Small shooting area
• Can spin when shot on sides or at corners. 
• It’s hard to pull out some types of arrows. 

How Long Does the Rinehart® 18-1 Broadhead Target Last?

Rinehart 18-1 is used in both crossbow shooting and target archery sports. It can stop different types of arrows including field points, expandable broadheads, and fixed blade broadheads, making it a must-have for any serious shooter. 

A Rinehart® 18-1 Broadhead Target can last a year at the very least before needing replacement. The target is made from a dense and heavy self-healing foam with self-healing properties that kicks in immediately after the arrow gets pulled out. 

Whether you’re a professional archer or a beginner, the Rinehart is a great choice.

For more, check out How Far Can a Bow Shoot? | Ranges by Draw Weight (With Chart).