Skip to Content

The 6 Best Similar Substitutes for Rum Extract

Bottle of rum extract sitting on a wooden table

Rum extract is a popular flavoring agent in baking and cooking, known for its distinctive rich and sweet profile reminiscent of aged rum. However, there are times when this extract is either unavailable or unsuitable for specific dietary needs or preferences. Finding an adequate substitute can make or break a dish in these cases.

The 6 top substitutes for rum extract include real rum, vanilla & almond extracts, brandy or cognac, and sweet alternatives like maple syrup and molasses. While each option offers distinct flavor profiles, they can effectively replace rum extract in various recipes.

Here are six substitutes that can replace rum extract while retaining the essence of the flavor or providing a unique twist:

1. Almond Extract

With its robust and nutty flavor, almond extract can be a delightful substitute if you want to introduce a different depth to your dish.

  • Substitution ratio: Due to its strong flavor, use half a teaspoon of almond extract for every teaspoon of rum extract.
  • Advantages: Almond extract can provide a nutty and warm undertone, especially favorable in baked goods.
  • Considerations: The taste will deviate significantly from the rum flavor, but almond extract might be the twist you need in recipes where the rum flavor isn’t dominant.

2. Brandy or Cognac

My travels introduced me to the depth of brandy and cognac. Both offer a richness that reminds me of rum’s complexity.

Both are derived from grapes and offer a rich depth reminiscent of the complexity of rum.

  • Substitution ratio: Use two tablespoons of brandy or cognac for every teaspoon of rum extract.
  • Advantages: These alternatives provide a fruity richness and complexity, elevating certain recipes, especially in desserts and sauces.
  • Considerations: Like rum, the alcohol content must be cooked off in most recipes, so be aware of its presence in no-bake dishes.

3. Maple Syrup


If you’re looking for a non-alcoholic alternative with a sweet profile, maple syrup might be your answer.

  • Substitution ratio: Use one tablespoon of maple syrup for every teaspoon of rum extract.
  • Advantages: The caramelized, woody maple syrup undertones can imitate some of the sweetness of rum, especially in desserts.
  • Considerations: Maple syrup is considerably sweeter and can add moisture to your recipe, so adjust other sweeteners and liquids accordingly.

4. Molasses

This old-world ingredient has a depth that’s hard to replicate. Molasses has been my go-to in recipes where the dark, profound sweetness of rum is essential.

A by-product of sugar refining, it offers a dark, rich sweetness that can mimic the depth of rum.

  • Substitution ratio: Use one tablespoon of molasses for every teaspoon of rum extract.
  • Advantages: In baked goods like gingerbread or certain pies, molasses can introduce a unique richness reminiscent of the depth found in rum.
  • Considerations: Molasses has a very distinct flavor. Ensure it complements the other flavors in your recipe.

5. Real Rum

In my earliest years of cooking, if rum extract was missing, I’d instinctively reach for the real thing. Dark or golden rum provides an authentic flavor and brings back memories of traditional recipes.

Naturally, the closest substitute to rum extract would be real rum.

  • Substitution ratio: Use two to three tablespoons of dark or golden rum for every teaspoon of rum extract.
  • Advantages: Using actual rum provides an authentic flavor, especially if you want a pronounced rum taste.
  • Considerations: While alcohol will cook off in baked goods, it might remain in no-bake dishes. Hence, consider the audience (like children or those avoiding alcohol) before substituting.

6. Vanilla Extract

Jelly Grandma's Homemade Vodka Vanilla Extract

Ah, the trusty vanilla extract! It doesn’t quite mirror rum, but its rich, aromatic profile has saved many a dessert in my kitchen. Use it in a straight swap, and while the result will be sweeter, the dish will still be delightful.

  • Substitution ratio: Use a one-to-one ratio—one teaspoon of vanilla extract for every teaspoon of rum extract.
  • Advantages: Vanilla is versatile and blends seamlessly with a range of other ingredients, making it ideal for cakes, cookies, and desserts.
  • Considerations: The result will be sweeter and less “rum-like,” but the vanilla can add a pleasant aromatic depth, especially my homemade version.

Though vanilla extract doesn’t emulate the exact flavor of rum, it has a rich profile that can be a suitable replacement in most recipes.

Final Thoughts

After 50+ years in the kitchen, I’ve learned that while ingredients like rum extract are unique, the heart of cooking is adaptability. With these substitutes, you’ll not only save your dish but might also stumble upon a new favorite flavor.

While rum extract imparts a unique flavor to dishes, there’s no need to panic if you run out or need an alternative. These six substitutes range from closely mimicking the taste of rum to introducing new flavor profiles that can make your dish stand out differently.

Remember, the art of cooking and baking lies in experimentation. Playing with these alternatives might help you discover a new favorite twist to your cherished recipes.

For more, don’t miss The 16 Best Substitutes for Rum in a Recipe or Mixer.